It’s April 8th, Bernie just ended his campaign, and in a fit of rage, you commit to not voting for Biden. He’s too cozy with wall street, he’s an accused predator, his mind is degenerating, he’s just another old white guy. All true and all problematic. But, the most important part of the past 3 sentences is the date – it was April 8th. The election isn’t tomorrow. Before making a commitment to not vote in April, I ask you to consider the following:
- “Bernie or Bust” ideology is anti-math and anti-democratic
At the end of the day, Biden won, and Bernie didn’t. Whatever unfair barriers got in the way of Bernie running away with the nomination on Super Tuesday (unfair corporate media coverage, lack of access to polling places in pro-Bernie areas), Bernie’s voters didn’t turn out like they said they would. Going against institutional power holders (media, corporations, white supremacy, voter suppression) is part of the game, even within the democratic party. The progressive movement has the burden of overcoming all of those things, and we didn’t do it. To simply write Biden off (no matter what his flaws are), just because you are salty that Bernie didn’t win goes against basic mathematical principles. If you believe in the basic democratic value of one person one vote and majority rule, then accept that Biden won.
The other side of the double-edged sword of Bernie’s idealism and big ideas is that it failed to appeal to two essential democratic voter demographics – older black people and suburban white women. Their voices are just as important as anyone’s. To my fellow Bernie supporters who are privileged and white – try to picture yourself talking to an older black Biden voter, and telling them that what did is wrong and bad for the U.S. Their people died for the right to vote, and they still face voter suppression today, and are still voting. You can’t tell them nothing. Period.
Demand fair representation of ideology in platform and cabinet
Biden still has to earn the progressive vote. Even though the combined totals of the moderate candidates in the democratic primary outnumbered the combined totals of the progressive totals (even if you include Yang with the progressives), the margin wasn’t that significant. I’m doing this by total votes, not delegate counts because the delegate system is just as stupid as the electoral college.
Biden needs to form a platform and a cabinet that is proportional to the ideological preferences of primary voters. He has time to do this. Let’s wait and see what he comes up with and then decide. If you judge his final platform and cabinet to be proportional, then you should vote for him. Just eyeballing the table above, the progressive platform should influence between 35-50% of the ticket platform and cabinet. His platform has already made significant movements leftward, and will only move further leftward considering huge impact the coronavirus has had. In that sense, Bernie did (somewhat) win the primary. One could argue that Bernie has made more of a political impact than elected presidents.
2. Bernie-or-Bust ideology is not how solidarity works, and could ultimately hurt the movement.
Imagine if the tables were turned, and Bernie won Super Tuesday by a slight margin, and a huge chunk of the reliable democratic voting block started considering sitting out the election, or voting for 45 in a protest vote. How would we feel about the Biden-or-Bust people? We would say they were sabotaging the movement, that they are just as bad as the 45-supporters. It would not only hurt the progressive movement, but it would hurt any chances of ever stopping 45-ism again. The Democratic Party is a big tent party, and sometimes you have to yield to the majority in the tent (but don’t yield too much – see #1).
3. Ask yourself, who ultimately suffers in a re-election of 45?
This is especially directed at my fellow privileged white Bernie supporters. Arguably more than any other presidential candidate in the history of the U.S. who stood a chance at actually getting elected, Bernie has unapologetically and radically advocated for the rights of oppressed people for his entire political life. If you love Bernie’s ideology so much, ask yourself:
- What happens to people of color with 4 more years of 45?
- To women?
- To LGBTQIA+ peoples?
- To native peoples?
- To poor people?
- The environment?
- To Workers?
- The National parks?
- To Children in cages?
- To access to family planning?
- To immigrants?
Failing to even take part in this thought exercise shows that your support of Bernie was more about your commitment to maintaining a self-image of righteousness and progressiveness than to those values themselves and to the people you claim to be allies of. Do you really stand for what Bernie stands for? Or do you love how Bernie affects your self-image?
4. The Senate is worth your enthusiasm
If, at this point, you are still salty, ask yourself: is it possible that we can just view Biden as a tool to get humane policy into law? Who has done more damage to democracy and the rights of oppressed people – Joe Biden, or Mitch McConnel? Biden or Susan Collins? Biden or Lindsey Graham?
Winning the presidency is important to an extent, but this is our best chance at flipping the Senate, you know, the body of government that actually turns bills into laws. Flipping the senate, according to the (albeit pro-Biden) press, is more possible under a Biden ticket than a Sanders ticket.
It’s difficult to get excited about Biden, but there are plenty of other Senate candidates to get excited about. Use your energy that you had for Bernie and go all in on supporting these swing state Senate candidates. Sometimes, offense is the best defense.
Support candidates here
Learn about and volunteer for candidates here:
Amy McGrath
Jaime Harrison
Sara Gideon
Mark Kelly
5. The planet, the planet, the planet
If, at this point, you are still salty, I ask you to consider the following.
- Is your responsibility to the movement more important than your responsibility to the sustainability of the planet?
Imagine your child in 10-20 years asking you:
“What were national parks like?”
“What was Miami like?”
“What was Manhattan like?”
“Why are people killing each other over water?”
Biden’s environmental platform, as it stands now, does not go far enough, but:
1. This is one policy area where the progressive platform can make the deepest inroads into the ticket platform.
2. This is our last chance to (somewhat) save the planet from irreversible damage. 45’s re-election will be the nail in the coffin. There is just too much at stake.
Reluctance to “take one for the team” when the “team” has screwed your movement over is understandable. What is difficult to understand, is reluctance when the “team” is human kind.
6. At the very least, advocate for voting rights and vote-by-mail**
Still salty, Biden still stucks. You simply cannot fathom voting for an accused sexual predator. But, deep down, your Bernie righteousness tells you you can still do something. A solution: register other people to vote, increase voter turnout, and advocate for early voting and vote-by-mail. Your hands are clean of voting for Biden and you can still justify to yourself that you are an ally of oppressed groups.
The GOP knows that higher voter turnout = Dems in office. That is why they are already mobilizing to force people to vote in person. COVID-19 a perfect storm for voter suppression – black and brown people are more likely to contract and die from the disease (resulting in less DEM votes) and people are less likely to risk their lives to vote in person. Here lies the solution and something to get fired up about advocating for: universal vote-by-mail. This would increase turnout and be COVID-19 responsible. 45 and the GOP know this is a disaster for 2020 and have already started fighting against it. 45 even said that it directly hurts the GOPs chances to ever win again. In Wisconsin this past week, the GOP refused to delay the primary election (which included a state supreme court seat), thus forcing people (especially the black and brown residents of Milwaukee, who already face a lack of polling places) to risk their lives and vote in person. However, universal vote-by-mail is not such a partisan issue as one would believe. Old white folks (read: GOP) love to vote by mail, and are also severely at risk from dying from COVID-19, which is presumably why some GOP representatives in some states are more open to considering it.
So, use that unmatched-never-before-seen-Berner enthusiasm and advocate for your allies’ right to vote. See below:
- FairFight – Stacy Abrams’ voter registration and anti-voter suppression organization:
- Call your local and state representatives and advocate for mail-in and early voting. Find your hour representative’s number here and your senator’s here
- Register voters in your area
- The Brennan Center also has a bunch of interesting voting projects
**Bernie-or-Bust Curious folks: feel free to justify to me how registering others to vote goes against Bernie’s values. Refusing to vote for Biden yourself I can (barely) understand. Completely giving up on your *supposed* allies, I cannot.